![]() Melden Fred Associate, 1848 posts | You have something interesting here. Perhaps a new form – something that begins as prose, then transmutes to standard poetic voice. On the other hand, nothing wrong with putting this into 3 parts (numbered or not – your choice) with different styles and voices. Or making it all poetry, unified. Another idea would be to state it as 3 parts: Thesis, Antithesis, Synthesis. Again, your decision. In any case, it has to be tightened because it’s rather wordy, covers a lot of ground, and the subject matter is not sufficiently profound or deep to warrant this many words. (Not to denigrate the subject, but it is about common-people experiences.) I’m wondering about “here on earth”. What were you trying to convey with the phrase? Perhaps a sub-theme to expand on? If so, expand. If not, I’d say drop it. Don’t be afraid to add some sub themes. At the beginning point where you are now, add more. You can always eliminate some later. When I say tighten the language, the “my illusions” should be just, “illusions”. I’ll save this for comparing with v.2. Alcuin |
![]() Julie herselffrom Here and There 302 posts | Thanks Alcuin. I'll try it out and see what happens! |
![]() Shannon McEwenfrom Canada 463 posts | First of all I hear ya, I've been in this place before and you say it well. I see an incredible poem in this, maybe pick some of the great images here and rework a poem? Then maybe write this like an article? Sort of a commentary on parenthood? Either way Julie, I think you have something here. ----- Life is what happens while you wait for great things. Life is what happens while you wait for great things. |
![]() Julie herselffrom Here and There 302 posts | I'm still experimenting, and want some feedback whether or not this rewrite is more effective. If not, I'll work the whole piece into a poem. Alcuin - your advice about adding in words at the early stage was inspired. I absolutely LOVED that . . . I'm aware I always need to cut back, but the freedom to add more first was liberating to the creative process. I'm not sure that it's clear in this piece, but it really helped me. |
![]() Leanne Hansonfrom Just west of the lounge room Associate, 3708 posts | I saw Papa Smurf's comment yesterday and was in total agreement, so I thought I'd wait and see what you produced and I'm glad I did, because this kind of fusion writing is really good for poetry. I think in the first version you had your degree "framed on the wall" - I actually wouldn't mind seeing that here, because "framed" has that double meaning which would be quite appropriate. The milk motif in that last part, coupled with the female God, make this really interesting. Very fertile and very feminine, but not in a way that should alienate any men. I would love to see more of this, I think it's a quite exciting direction. |
![]() Julie herselffrom Here and There 302 posts | Thanks, Leanne! I added 'framed' back in . . . |
![]() Rice Janelle 35 posts | I really like the "all that sour milk I poured it down the drain". It speaks to me of accepting your life and current state and not allowing it to bring you down. Oh, and of course "big girl panties"! That made me laugh I love the feminine form of God and speaking to her like she is a person, inviting her in for coffee. Trying to listen... it really speaks to Moms.
|
![]() Melden Fred Associate, 1848 posts | ![]() I have a bit of trouble only with, "in the fall that washes away visions of". Crumbling and washing don't go together. Perhaps "shedding" or another verb more compatible with crumbling and falling - lots of possibilities here. Very nicely done. Alcuin |
![]() Paradiso, Tracey Associate, 1902 posts | I read the original, and can't remember it to compare it to what you've created here. I love this. I think it's spot on, cleverly crafted and "conscious." A must-read for every "new" mother.
|