2- Derma Kaput
on Apr. 17 2007
Outside of that, I think this is an excellent book idea. With a good illustrator, I could imagine kids loving a story like this. I'd even consider adding more stanzas with an even greater escalation of ridiculous details - only because the idea is so ripe.
3- Jen
on Apr. 18 2007
Thanks Tracey and Derma!
I really appreciate your comments and suggestions.
When I read it outloud it seems to flow pretty smoothly but since I wrote it, it's hard for me to tell. I think a few more stanzas would be make the story more visually appealing for an illustrator to work with too.
Since you both are having rhythm problems, there must be some. I've been researching what editors are looking for with rhyming picture book and now I'm more confused then before. Some say that each line has to have the exact same count while others say the rhythm flows better with similar counts but not exact.
I guess I'm just plain confused
4- Derma Kaput
on Apr. 18 2007
5- Shannon McEwen
on Apr. 18 2007
Second, I like this. It is definately marketable. I agree you could possible add imagery for pictures.
Some suggestions:
The line "As big as ten big toes" seems to have an extra beat. so my suggestion would be to either remove the "big" or add to the next line something like "It was SUPER jumbo size"
In the line "With a big grin" maybe add "With such a big grin"??
In the line "With out a care" there seems to be just a little thing missing but I can't point it out. Maybe saying it like "With not even a care"?
Lastly you can ignore all of my suggestions they are just that, becuase I love the poem and will read it to my son tonight before bed!
Life is what happens while you wait for great things.
Life is what happens while you wait for great things.
6- Derma Kaput
on Apr. 18 2007
7- Jen
on Apr. 19 2007
Thanks!
I'm trying
8- Jen
on Apr. 19 2007
Hi again,
I have one more question then I'll stop bothering you guys.
Which stanza do you like better:
Spaghetti and meat balls
He'd slurp up each bite
Scrambling an egg
With bacon in flight
OR
Spaghetti and meat balls
He'd bounce off his toe
While scrambling an egg
And kneading bread dough
9- Derma Kaput
on Apr. 20 2007
10- Anstey
on Apr. 20 2007
"Hi again,
I have one more question then I'll stop bothering you guys.
Which stanza do you like better:
Spaghetti and meat balls
He'd slurp up each bite
Scrambling an egg
With bacon in flightOR
Spaghetti and meat balls
He'd bounce off his toe
While scrambling an egg
And kneading bread dough"
i prefer the action of bacon in flight visually far more than kneading dough.
for that reason alone, i'd go with it. One tends to assume you are eventually going to get this illustrated, and I think eyeing illustrateable verbs makes sense.
- stephan
11- Jen
on May 3 2007
Thanks everyone for the help! I really appreciate your time and efforts
1- Tracey
on Apr. 17 2007
I keep wondering about the imagery in the first few stanzas (1-5) and whether or not it's specific enough. I have a hard time imagining what kind of illustrations will accompany those stanzas. The other stanzas read with crystal clear, fun imagery.
I think there might be a few spots where the rhythm is a bit off, but you'd be better off asking one of our resident experts about that.
Stick with it!