2- Caelanwolf
on Nov. 23 2007
3- Alcuin of York
on Nov. 24 2007
I have been a student of history for perhaps three decades. As memory best serves me, it is a peculiarity of our age to make a virtue of avoiding honing the expression of language. The modern conceit is to consider extemporaneous (and even impulsive) expression to be at least the equivalent of well considered and thoughtful use of language. I disagree. You might want to see my poem, "Tossing Paint" for a more extensive comment on that tendency.
Alcuin
4- Caelanwolf
on Nov. 24 2007
5- Jerseydanielgibson
on Nov. 26 2007
wow, i feel like i'm watching a table tennis match...
----- Wot, no tea?
I'm standing in the corner of Winslow, Arizona, and whoops! I'm in the wrong song! -Tissi Germain
1- Alcuin of York
on Nov. 23 2007
"Some days I cannot breathe / cannot breathe without a pain / a lump, a knot inside my lungs / beneath my ribs / near to my heart. / A hole in my chest / in place of a heart..."
Of course, it's OK as prose, but I really think it would make better poetry. In either form, you have a lot of redundant and unnecessary words. Example: "but it lives there no more". By saying "should reside", you've already indicated it isn't there. If you wanted to express that it was once there but is no longer so, the previous phrase could be"where my heart once was", which implies clearly that it is no longer there.
I do like the feelings and ideas expressed here, but I think you could tighten up the writing to make it more effective. As for changing it to poetry, this is perhaps an expression of my own bias as a poet, but in any case, this piece would adapt quite nicely.
Alcuin