Skip to main content Help Control Panel

Shakespeare's Monkeys

Infinite Monkeys. Infinite Typewriters.

More in Pimpin' your Poems

Vee-ku

Rhiannon Jones -- on Feb. 12 2007

OK, I'm pimping this one.... Your thoughts? In my effort to use alliteration, did I obscure the subject of this haiku?
Vast ominous white
Black vee’s spiral a vortex
Swoop down voracious
avatar
Stephan Ansteyfrom Lowell, MA
Associate, 6232 posts

on Feb. 12 2007


Yeah, I think this is too obscure for a haiku of any sort.

Haiku need to be very present with a clear moment of revelation and a seasonal/nature theme.

I'm missing that quite a bit.

Still, I admire the attempt! Keep going!


  • stephan
Rhiannon Jones
88 posts

inspired from anstey on Feb. 13 2007


Anstey:

Thanks, Stephan. I thought that the "swoop" would be the moment of revelation....it was supposed to be about vultures! I'll keep tryin'.....
avatar
Stephan Ansteyfrom Lowell, MA
Associate, 6232 posts

inspired from anstey on Feb. 13 2007


Rhiannon Jones:

I think the lack of impact onthe swoop is directly from the lack of clarity in the previous two lines. At least, that's what I think.


  • stephan
Rhiannon Jones
88 posts

inspired from anstey on Feb. 13 2007


Anstey:

Okey Dokey. Here was the original version, before I got all crazy with the letter V. Does this work any better?

Sky ominous white
Black v-wings spiralling down
Vultures swoop earthward
avatar
Stephan Ansteyfrom Lowell, MA
Associate, 6232 posts

inspired from anstey on Feb. 13 2007


" Anstey: Okey Dokey. Here was the original version, before I got all crazy with the letter V. Does this work any better? Sky ominous white
Black v-wings spiralling down
Vultures swoop earthward "


Actually, yes. I like this much more. I think the clarity helps a lot. I'm still not sold on the moment of revelation, however, it's there -- even if i think it could be stronger. All in all, a much more worthy effort, I think.


  • stephan
avatar
Kath Abela Wilsonfrom after the dance
290 posts

on Apr. 1 2007


I think that even if there were a lot of vultures, the moment of revelation needs only one. If the last line were changed to

 "a vulture..."

it would be more ominous and effective.

I do think the original had a swoop of revelation too...

Share
* Invite participants
* Share at Facebook
* Share at Twitter
* Share at LinkedIn
* Reference this page
Monitor
Recent files
Forums »
See also