Bad Poetry?

Fascinating thread. I won't comment on the existence or non-existence of bad poetry - my first attempts deserved metals in the bad poetry hall of fame. Jeez I still have no idea if what I write is any good. What I do practice is listening to well founded critical comments, and taking them seriously.  Perhaps that might be a difference - I have written ... I don't even want to count them ... many long, carefully thought out reviews, only to be told I was off my rocker and dead and head was a meaningful rhyme (not making that one up). I have received an almost equal number of reviews that "didn't get it" or tell me I should "cheer up" or did I notice it "didn't rhyme"

In the end, I don't think the quality of the writing makes too much difference, what will make a difference is the attitude of the writer.  I can only say what has worked for me is listening, and learning (this is a continuing process) to follow my own instincts and write as honestly as I can. When I wrote to make an impression on others (yes, and I am embarrassed about that) it was drivel. When I write honestly and then listen to the opinions of those I trust, my work becomes polished and distilled. None of this could have been accomplished outside of a critical community - I am insanely grateful for the honesty I have received about what I write (even the comment, "you know I think this is likely the worst thing you've ever written" - sometimes you really have to smack me in the head!).

So not to make this all about me (insane egomaniac that I am), but I simply don't feel qualified to judge another's writing as good or bad.  I like and dislike many poems (including some of the best loved classics...) but lack the critical ability to make any other comment on a piece of writing.  Leanne said something like all writing is redeemable (gross paraphrase) and I initially scoffed, but who am I to say what is and what isn't? If it were not for initial faith in me by other more experienced and talented poets I never would have improved and would have given up the whole writing thing (never could get into the sycophantic circle jerk).

I think this is likely enough brainless babbling for one night and one topic, but thanks very much for the thought exercise, I quite enjoyed it!